W-D-L 1–1–2 · form DLLW
Cibao have played 4 matches in CONCACAF Caribbean Club Championship (1W, 1D, 2L), scoring 4 and conceding 5.
W-D-L 0–3–1 · form DDDL
Atlético Pantoja have played 4 matches in CONCACAF Caribbean Club Championship (0W, 3D, 1L), scoring 4 and conceding 6.
12 meetings · Cibao 5–4–3 Atlético Pantoja