J. Henderson trophies
- Eredivisie · 2024/2025 · 2nd Place
- Community Shield · 2022 · Winner
- FA Cup · 2021/2022 · Winner
- League Cup · 2021/2022 · Winner
- Premier League · 2021/2022 · 2nd Place
- UEFA Champions League · 2021/2022 · 2nd Place
- UEFA European Championship · 2021 · 2nd Place
- Community Shield · 2020 · 2nd Place
- Premier League · 2019/2020 · Winner
- Community Shield · 2019 · 2nd Place
- FIFA Intercontinental Cup · 2019 · Winner
- UEFA Super Cup · 2019 · Winner
- Premier League · 2018/2019 · 2nd Place
- UEFA Champions League · 2018/2019 · Winner
- UEFA Champions League · 2017/2018 · 2nd Place
- Premier League Asia Trophy · 2017 · Winner
- League Cup · 2015/2016 · 2nd Place
- UEFA Europa League · 2015/2016 · 2nd Place
- Premier League · 2013/2014 · 2nd Place
- FA Cup · 2011/2012 · 2nd Place
- League Cup · 2011/2012 · Winner
- Community Shield · Winner
- Community Shield · 2nd Place
- Eredivisie · 2nd Place
- FA Cup · 2nd Place
- FA Cup · Winner
- FIFA Intercontinental Cup · Winner
- League Cup · 2nd Place
- League Cup · Winner
- Premier League · Winner
- Premier League · 2nd Place
- Premier League Asia Trophy · Winner
- UEFA Champions League · 2nd Place
- UEFA Champions League · Winner
- UEFA Europa League · 2nd Place
- UEFA European Championship · 2nd Place
- UEFA Super Cup · Winner