M. McNulty career clubs
| Season | Team |
|---|---|
| 2025 | Shamrock Rovers |
| 2024 | Shamrock Rovers |
| 2023 | Orange County SC |
| 2021 | Dundee Utd |
| 2020 | Dundee Utd |
| 2020 | Scotland |
| 2019 | Reading |
| 2018 | Reading |
| 2017 | Coventry |
| 2016 | Sheffield Utd |
| 2015 | Sheffield Utd |
| 2014 | Sheffield Utd |
| 2013 | Livingston |
| 2012 | Livingston |
| 2011 | Livingston |
| 2010 | Livingston |
| 2009 | Livingston |